They both have a MAJOR problem. They claim ONLY the Centerfield view of a swing will show the truth. Yet, the same swing from the same player, from a different camera angle, shows their conclusion about the spinal axis plane that they see from the CF view.....is wrong.

How can the same swing show two different techniques? It doesn't. But it proves their conclusion is wrong. HI.com's swing teaching is supported by both views. Their teaching is only supported by the CF view. And it is fully debunked by the side view. Which AUTOMATICALLY means their view is false. It AUTOMATICALLY means they have made an analysis mistake. Do you think either will admit it?

High level hitters swing the barrel about the forearms instead of the spine/shoulders, and occasionally, depending on pitch location, the plane created by the forearm turn will align with the shoulders. And give a spinal axis APPEARANCE....yet is not about the spine. They jump to a conlusion, and then claim spinal rotation as an absolute. This Manny clip PROVES they are wrong.



It doesn't suggest they are wrong. IT PROVES THEY ARE WRONG.

CLEARLY....extremely clearly....so clear that you have to be misleading people to say otherwise....this bat is not swung about his spine. It is swung about the forearms. Notice the bats roughly 90 degree relationship to the rear forearm all the way through. Duh.

This critical analysis mistake comes because they pay no attention to the giddyup. They give zero consideration to where/when/how the barrel is accelerated. It is impossible to analyze accurately until you know what is load and what is launch.

And their statement "the CF view shows what we're talking about"....CLEARLY DOES NOT SHOW THE TRUTH. It is a fabrication. It is impossible for the same swing to show two different swing patterns.

If they would swing to duplicate, which neither ever has, they would find the truth. Why isn't truth their goal? How, when presented with this Manny clip, can they, with a straight face claim "the other camera angle shows the truth". Both cameras show the same thing!! Who do they think they are talking to? Children? Stepford Wives? Have they no concern? Are they willing to just sell kids down the river?

Um....Yes. They are.