
It PROVES.....that they are LOOKING and not FEELING.
This girl has a STRONG SnF load....enhanced by her back and scap resistance. Which means it is IMPOSSIBLE for her to be all back all forward.
Just because the slack was taken out at a different time.....due to a different style.....doesn't mean it hasn't been taken out.
The proving frames.....

THAT....is a PULLING leg....not a pushing leg. All back all forward hitters PUSH their barrel. This girl does not.
Drive by advice givers are as dangerous as it gets.
You will never analyze swings properly until you FEEL what is happening in the swing. Good luck feeling if you don't swing a bat yourself.
http://www.hittingillustrated.com/images/KiwiBrooke.gif
OH
MY
You see....when you know what is absolute and what is style....you can see these things.
But....you have to make a side by side so the mindless can see it.
My point of posting the clips where to receive feedback. I can care less who's opinions agree with who. Some times when you look at something long enough you miss things or see what you want to see. It is my responsibility to decipher what information I use. I am not a back yard Rec dad with no experience. I am her head coach as well as her hitting instructor. Her swing was built from the ground up my me starting when she was 5. She nor I are any where near perfect but we both stride for perfection. As I stated in the OP this was her first attempt at the changes I was asking her to make. I appreciate all comments and critiques and look forward to sharing the progress we make over the off-season.
Teacherman.. Thanks for the feedback